تاريخ النشر: · آخر تحديث:

روسيا ترفض ضمانات أمنية على نمط «عضوية شبه بالناتو» لأوكرانيا

间歇 News: vélez al事 news daily brief. Russia rejected any security-guarantee arrangement that would give Ukraine NATO membership or quasi-membership status. The move contradicts a US claim that Moscow was ready to consider guarantees resembling Article 5, while reported US scenarios linked Ukraine's NATO accession to territorial concessions.

أبرز النقاط

  • ,都要守护!
  • ]:
  • ،
  • ؛
  • ،
  • ،
  • ،

لماذا يهمّ ذلك

تُظهرiov negotiation المواقف: غير متوافقة بشأن شكل الضمانات الأمنية الغربية لأوكرانيا. فالمقترحات الأمريكية المعلنة تربط الأمن وعضوية الناتو بقرارات إقليمية، بينما تشترط روسيا الاعتراف بأن أوكرانيا لن تنضم إلى حلف الناتو. كما لم يتأكد Ukraine والولايات المتحدة أنهما تتفقان على معنى الضمانات المشابهة للمادة 5.

ماذا حدث

úm said Russia rejected any arrangement resembling Ukrainian NATO membership or quasi-membership. Deputy Foreign Minister Сергій Рябков said Moscow would not even search for a formula on that issue and wanted recognition that Ukraine would not join NATO. He nevertheless said security guarantees could be discussed in the context of Russia's own security and after that recognition.

The statement came against Jared Kushner's claim that Washington had persuaded Russia to consider guarantees resembling NATO Article 5. Russian readiness to discuss such guarantees was not confirmed in the supplied reporting.

Volodymyr Zelensky said he was uncertain whether Ukraine and the United States shared the same understanding of Article 5-like guarantees. He confirmed that US representatives had raised the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for withdrawing from Donbas, but said Ukraine would not surrender territory that could enable new Russian offensives.

After the coalition-of-the-willing meeting in Berlin, Zelensky said Europe would participate in negotiations with Russia to end the war. The United States said any final agreement would require the consent of both Ukraine and Russia.

كيف تصفه المصادر الأوكرانية

تركز Ukrainian coverage على رفض Russia الثابت لأي ضمانات على نمط NATO أو عضوية شبه بالناتو، وتقابله بادعاء أمريكي بأن Moscow مستعدة للنظر في ضمانات تشبه المادة 5. كما تبرزsources عدم يقين Zelensky من توافق Ukraine والولايات المتحدة على المعنى المقصود، وأهمية موافقة الشعب Ukrainian على أي ترتيبات أمنية ورفض Kyiv التنازل عن أي أرضية.

كيف تصفه المصادر الدولية

يركز international reporting على السيناريوهات الأمريكية التي تربط عضوية Ukraine في NATO بالتنازل الإقليمي وجمود خط الجبهة وضمانات ثنائية أو دولية. ويشير إلى أن انضمام Ukraine يتطلب موافقة جميع دول NATO، وأن分歧 الأوروبيين مستمر بشأن جدوى متابعة Membership، بينما تصف European negotiators المتطلبات Russian packages بأنها maximalist.

أين تختلف الروايات

There is a direct disagreement over Russian readiness to consider Article 5-like guarantees: US envoy Jared Kushner said Washington had persuaded Moscow to examine them, while Sergei Ryabkov rejected any arrangement involving Ukrainian NATO membership or quasi-membership, and Russian readiness was not confirmed by Russia in the available reporting.

European participants also differ on Ukraine's prospective NATO membership. Emmanuel Macron said it was time to discuss it, while the German side did not support further consideration. A report attributed to Friedrich Merz said Ukraine would not join the alliance during his lifetime.

الخلفية

Russia's broader demands include restrictions on NATO troops and equipment in Ukraine, an end to Western arms deliveries, reductions of NATO infrastructure in Eastern Europe to its 1997 level, withdrawal of certain missiles capable of reaching Russia, and removal of French and British proposals on nuclear protection for other European states. European negotiators characterize these demands as maximalist initial negotiating positions.

Ukraine's NATO accession would require unanimous approval from all member states. The US described the possible guarantees as bilateral arrangements similar to those Israel has. Two reported US scenarios included either transferring the remaining Ukrainian-controlled Donbas territories in exchange for full NATO membership or freezing the conflict along the current front line and retaining part of Donbas under Ukrainian control under international guarantees.