ضابط أمني أوكراني يpatrick shedding light on the ‘Carthage’ case amid allegations of political influence
On November 18, 2026, Major General Serhii Duka, a Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) officer and figure in the “Carthage” case, testified before the Verkhovna Rada’s Temporary Investigative Commission. Duka acknowledged that he had no factual evidence to support his allegations that anti-corruption agencies fabricate cases and use them to pressure senior state officials. He also said he did not know whether he had been formally dismissed from his SBU position and that he had learned of the possible dismissal from the media.
أبرز النقاط
- Testified before the Verkhovna Rada’s Temporary Investigative Commission on November 18, 2026, regarding the “Carthage” case.
- The National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP) and Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Office (SAPO) detained Duka on April 4 during the “Carthage” operation.
- Duka acknowledged that he had no factual evidence supporting his claims that anti-corruption agencies create leverage against the government or fabricate cases.
- The Higher Anti-Corruption Court placed Duka under detention for 60 days on November 6, with a bail alternative of 65 million hryvnias.
- Duka said he did not know whether he had been dismissed from his SBU position and had learned about the possible dismissal from the media.
- The court reported that the 65-million-hryvnia bail was paid through 1,636 transactions, with the largest payment being 1 million hryvnias.
- Duka said he broke two of his own smartphones with an axe during the April 4 search, saying he did not understand what was happening and was protecting operational contacts.
لماذا يهمّ ذلك
Duka’s testimony raises questions about the independence of the NACP, the SAPO and the judicial process. His claims about an alleged instruction to “not move” cases involving NACP personnel and NACP Director Semen Kryvonos relate directly to the handling and possible non-implementation of corruption investigations. The dispute over how the 65-million-hryvnia bail was collected also concerns working conditions and internal financial support within the SBU. After the hearing, the commission summoned several people involved in the alleged events to test his claims.
ماذا حدث
Serhii Duka testified before the parliamentary Temporary Investigative Commission on November 18 in the “Carthage” case. According to the commission hearing, he said that in autumn 2025, SBU chief Vasyl Malyuk, after returning from the Office of the President, told him and his deputies not to pursue cases concerning alleged corruption by NACP employees, including NACP Director Semen Kryvonos. Duka said the materials for a suspension notice concerning Kryvonos had been prepared by the end of 2025, but he did not identify who made the political decision not to hurry with signing it and did not know whom Malyuk had briefed in the Office of the President.
Duka also stated that he did not know whether he had been dismissed from his position as first deputy head of the SBU’s Department for the Protection of National State Security, that he had not been shown any order or document confirming his status, and that he had learned of the possible dismissal from the media. He claimed that he could not be discharged from military service in the SBU before the end of martial law, while also acknowledging that the question of his official position remained unresolved.
Duka acknowledged that his broader allegations about anti-corruption agencies, media and business interests creating leverage against the government and President Volodymyr Zelenskyy were analytical conclusions for which he had not produced evidence. He also denied that SBU employees were forced to raise his bail. The court’s records showed that the 65 million hryvnias was contributed through 1,636 transactions by individuals, with no legal entities among the contributors.
During his testimony, Duka said that he had broken two of his own smartphones with an axe during the April 4 search, explaining that he did not understand what was happening and was protecting operational contacts. The NACP had previously opened a criminal proceeding over resistance to detectives, which was assigned to the State Bureau of Investigation. Duka also denied that NACP detective Ruslan Mahamedrasulov participated in the “Midas” case concerning theft at Energoatom, whereas the NACP had officially confirmed his involvement in documenting people linked to corruption schemes in that operation.
كيف تصفه المصادر الأوكرانية
Ukrainian coverage focused on Duka’s testimony before the commission, his uncertain employment status and his claims about instructions to leave corruption investigations inactive. Particular attention was paid to the collection of the bail, alleged threats by NACP personnel and his criticism of the publication of lists of bail contributors. His most consequential claims about coordinated actions involving anti-corruption agencies, media outlets and Tomas Fiala were presented alongside his admission that he had no factual evidence. Coverage also linked the “Carthage” case to the proceedings involving Semen Kryvonos and the subsequent closure of one of those proceedings.
أين تختلف الروايات
Duka denied that SBU employees were forced to collect money for his bail, while his lawyer said the contributions were made voluntarily. The court confirmed 1,636 payments and that no legal entities were among the contributors; Ukrainian media also reported that employees were asked to contribute 50,000 hryvnias and unit leaders 150,000 hryvnias. Duka denied that Ruslan Mahamedrasulov participated in the “Midas” case, while the NACP confirmed that the detective documented people linked to corruption schemes. A SAPO prosecutor said Duka and his armed security resisted detectives and spent two hours destroying evidence with an axe; Duka acknowledged breaking only two of his own smartphones and denied carrying a weapon. The Anti-Corruption Action Center said Duka’s parents-in-law had received Russian passports, whereas Duka said he did not know whether they had them. Duka also gave inconsistent formulations of his employment status, initially saying he could not be dismissed from the SBU during martial law and later clarifying that this concerned military service, while his SBU position could be ended.
الخلفية
Duka was detained during the “Carthage” operation on April 4, 2026. On November 6, the Higher Anti-Corruption Court placed him under detention for 60 days with an alternative of 65 million hryvnias in bail. He left the detention facility on November 13 after the full bail amount was paid. The SBU announced an internal review based on the “Carthage” materials, dismissed two officials involved in the investigation and said it was cooperating with the NACP and SAPO. Two proceedings involving Semen Kryvonos concerned an alleged fictitious adoption in 2009 and land allocation in Obukhiv district in 2014. The NACP said Duka’s unit provided operational support to the investigations. The announcement of a suspension notice for Kryvonos was later disputed by the Office of the Prosecutor General, which removed the relevant registry entry as erroneous, while the State Bureau of Investigation closed a proceeding concerning the alleged falsification of documents.